How can I use AI without losing my critical thinking?

The short answer

Use AI to examine your reasoning while keeping the work of judgment with yourself. Form a view, ask the system to challenge it, check important claims against their sources, and explain the final decision in your own words. Maxim’s essays describe both the value of working with AI and the risk of repeatedly accepting fluent answers before doing that work.

A well-written answer is easy to mistake for the best available answer.

Maxim Gorbachev, How to Think Clearly When the Stakes Are High

Formulate the problem before accepting the answer

Write down what you are trying to decide, what you already know, and what remains uncertain. That gives you something to compare with the response. Otherwise, the system’s first framing can become your framing before you have considered whether it fits the problem.

AI Didn’t Replace Us. It Made Us Optional describes the difference between thinking an idea through and selecting a ready-made idea. A useful tool can make that selection easy. Keeping a short record of your own reasoning makes the difference easier to notice.

From AI Didn’t Replace Us. It Made Us Optional.

Question agreement as carefully as disagreement

In How to Think Clearly When the Stakes Are High, Maxim describes using ChatGPT to organize material and prepare working drafts. The gain came with substantial work of his own: supplying context, correcting errors, revisiting documents, and deciding which questions mattered.

He also noticed that an AI agreeing with his objection did not prove the objection was right. Ask what evidence supports a position, what has been left out, and what would change your mind. Apply those questions to a reassuring answer as well as an uncomfortable one.

From How to Think Clearly When the Stakes Are High

Bring the answer back to its evidence

A confident explanation can make a question feel settled. Reopen the material it claims to explain. Can you find the passage behind the conclusion? Does the conclusion depend on a detail the system was never given? Can you explain the connection without repeating the generated wording?

Maxim’s account concerns preparation in an ongoing dispute. It reports his experience of doing more work independently, while retaining a role for professional expertise. The essay does not establish that a convincing draft settles the underlying dispute or proves a proposed approach will succeed.

From How to Think Clearly When the Stakes Are High

Keep some practice outside the conversation

Do You Still Know How to Think? recommends deliberately exercising skills that convenient tools can leave unused. The practical invitation is to read, recall, calculate, write, or discuss something before asking a system to complete it for you.

A small exercise is to summarize an argument from memory, then compare it with both the original and an AI summary. Examine what each version omitted. The purpose is to keep participating in the reasoning, including when assistance makes the finished output arrive faster.

From Do You Still Know How to Think? · AI Didn’t Replace Us. It Made Us Optional.

Read the original essays

  1. How to Think Clearly When the Stakes Are High

    A personal account of using AI productively while checking its answers and one’s own assumptions.

  2. AI Didn’t Replace Us. It Made Us Optional.

    Explains the concern that assistance can remove the practice of forming a thought.

  3. Do You Still Know How to Think?

    Invites readers to deliberately practice abilities they might otherwise leave to tools.